Skip to main content
Software und Anwendung für AutoCAD Plant 3D · Autodesk Authorized Training Center · Frankfurt am Main Deutsch · Español · +49 69 9450725-0 · vertrieb@seitz-ingenieure.de

Plant 3D Practical Knowledge

AutoCAD Plant 3D, AVEVA E3D and Smart 3D compared

Three programs for 3D plant design, three manufacturers. Here you will find what Autodesk, AVEVA and Hexagon say about their own software – with a source for every statement. This shows you quickly where the differences lie and which questions you should clarify for your project.

With us you will find solutions for your tasks. We have been an Autodesk ATCATC – Autodesk Authorized Training Center Training center authorized by Autodesk. A. Seitz Ingenieur GmbH has been an Autodesk ATC since 2011. Background and sources › since 2011 and teach AutoCAD Plant 3D. The information on AVEVA and Hexagon comes from their websites; we do not state prices of other manufacturers.

Three programs, different fields of application

All three programs design plants and piping in 3D, with piping specs, isometrics and bills of materials. AutoCAD Plant 3D is a toolset in AutoCAD. AVEVA E3D Design is the successor of AVEVA PDMS. Intergraph Smart 3D from Hexagon emerged in 2014 from SmartPlant 3D and SmartMarine 3D.

Comparison by criteria

Manufacturer information, sources at the end of the page.

CriterionAutoCAD Plant 3DAVEVA E3D DesignIntergraph Smart 3D
ManufacturerAutodeskAVEVAHexagon (Intergraph brand)
Basis and licenseToolset in AutoCAD, also in the AEC Collection [Q1]Part of AVEVA Unified Engineering [Q2, Q3]–
Predecessor–AVEVA PDMS, neither sold nor supported since 1 April 2024 [Q2]SmartPlant 3D and SmartMarine 3D, merged into Smart 3D in 2014 [Q4]
Use according to the manufacturer3D plant design and piping design based on AutoCAD [Q1]complex plants in process-intensive industries such as energy, chemicals and shipbuilding [Q3]“mission-critical project requirements” [Q5]
Piping specs and catalogsSpec Editor and catalogs in the project [Q1]–Smart Reference Data for catalogs and piping specs [Q5]
IsometricsIsogen technologyDrawings and documents directly from the model [Q3]Isogen isometrics [Q6]
CollaborationAutodesk Forma (Cloud)Teams at several locations working on the same project data at the same time [Q3]–
Clash detectionwith Navisworksin the program across all disciplines [Q3]–
As-built and laser scanIntegrate point cloud from ReCapImport laser scans [Q3]–

“–” means: we found no information on this from the manufacturer. It does not mean that the program cannot do it.

When AutoCAD Plant 3D is a good fit

Questions you should clarify for your project.

  • Your team works with AutoCAD and exchanges DWGDWG – AutoCAD drawing format AutoCAD file format for drawings and 3D models; AutoCAD Plant 3D and AutoCAD P&ID also save in this format. Background and sources › files with partners
  • You want P&IDR&I – Piping and instrumentation diagram Flow diagram showing all pipes, valves, equipment and instrumentation of a plant (P&ID, Piping and Instrumentation Diagram). Background and sources › diagrams (AutoCAD P&ID) and the 3D model in one project
  • You design in existing plants with point clouds from ReCap and check clashes in Navisworks
  • You want piping specs to DIN ENDIN – German Institute for Standardization “DIN” before a number means that the standard is published in Germany by the German Institute for Standardization. Background and sources ›EN – European Standard European Standard, developed by CEN (general) or CENELEC (electrical engineering). Background and sources ›, project templates and training from a single source

Switching and project start

Before a switch, we clarify with you which standards you want to adopt: piping specs, catalogs, tags, title blocks and isometric style. This results in your project in AutoCAD Plant 3D – with ASEING PlantConfig Pro as the template and ASEING Piping Catalogs to DIN EN.

Frequently asked questions

What is the successor of AVEVA PDMS?

AVEVA names AVEVA E3D Design as the successor. According to AVEVA, PDMS has been neither sold nor supported since 1 April 2024.

What is Smart 3D?

Intergraph Smart 3D is Hexagon's 3D plant design software. In 2014, SmartPlant 3D, SmartMarine 3D and SmartPlant 3D Materials Handling were merged into it.

Is there other plant design software based on AutoCAD besides AutoCAD Plant 3D?

Yes, for example CADWorx Plant Professional from Hexagon. According to the manufacturer it runs on AutoCAD or BricsCAD and works with DWG files.

Terms, background and sources 5 terms on this page

Brief explanations for reference. They do not replace the standard or code itself.

ATC – Autodesk Authorized Training Center

Training center authorized by Autodesk. A. Seitz Ingenieur GmbH has been an Autodesk ATC since 2011.

DWG – AutoCAD drawing format

AutoCAD file format for drawings and 3D models; AutoCAD Plant 3D and AutoCAD P&ID also save in this format.

R&I – Piping and instrumentation diagram

Flow diagram showing all pipes, valves, equipment and instrumentation of a plant (P&ID, Piping and Instrumentation Diagram).

Symbols and drawing rules: DIN EN ISO 10628-1 and -2. Identification letters for instrumentation: DIN EN 62424 or ISA-5.1.

DIN – German Institute for Standardization

“DIN” before a number means that the standard is published in Germany by the German Institute for Standardization.

DIN was founded in 1917 as the Standards Committee of German Industry. If “DIN EN” or “DIN EN ISO” precedes the number, a European or international standard has been adopted unchanged as a German standard.

EN – European Standard

European Standard, developed by CEN (general) or CENELEC (electrical engineering).

Every member country must adopt an EN unchanged as a national standard – in Germany as “DIN EN …”. Conflicting national standards are withdrawn.

Sources and origins